Weindependently evaluateall of our passport . If you snap on links we provide , we may have compensation .
Whether it ’s a vacation , Sunday dinner party , or just time for a casserole , our favorite roasting Pan anticipate gas - desirable roasts every clip .
In This Article
Better Homes & Gardens
Whether you ’re tasked with making a joint for a holiday social occasion or you just want to whip up a casserole , a ridicule goat god is the key to success . With so many styles and sizes , however , it can be unmanageable to settle which is the best roasting pan for your penury .
“ maintain even heat , permit sufficient air flow , and [ having ] multiple uses all element into looking at the right pan to purchase , ” saysMatt Gillett , owner of Saddleback Barbecue and The Slice .
Credit:Better Homes & Gardens
What We Tested
To find the good roasting pans , we cautiously tested 24 pans and determined how well or ill they make fun a chicken and potatoes . Then , we place each roasting pan found ondesign , carrying out , andease of cleaning . For more info on how we tested these pans , check outour lab testing processbelow .
Our Top Picks
Best Overall
Williams Sonoma Stainless Steel Ultimate Roaster with Rack
This stainless steel genus Pan is built to last , various and make a beautiful intro on the table .
It can be clayey when loaded with large cut of marrow .
Whether you ’re cooking for a crowd during the holidays or prepping a weeknight repast , this Williams Sonoma roaster has a sturdy , fashionable design that produces delectable results . Equipped with a obliterable roasting rack , the pan ’s unstained sword grammatical construction assure even heating and prevents bewilder , stimulate it our top pick in this family .
Credit: Williams Sonoma
We used the pan to develop chicken and pork shoulder joint roasts , and were impressed with the cooking performance , as well as the pan ’s aesthetic that transition well from the oven to the board .
Several thoughtful conception features summate to the appeal of this roaster , let in high-pitched side that lose weight splattering to keep your oven neat . It also sport easy to - grasp handgrip for lifting the pan with oven mitts on . Plus , a nonreactive cookery surface also makes it fantabulous for prepping stovetop gravies and sauces .
The pan offer tolerable size and deepness , with a capacity that holds up to 20 pounds . During examination , we noticed the cooking pan was a bit heavy when fully charge with big cut of pith . And while it is design to be nonstick and is listed as dishwashing machine good by the producer , hired hand washing is required to keep length of service . For best results , a nylon scrub pad and finely - powdery cleanser are recommend .
Thios pan offers adequate size and depth and can hold up to 20 pounds of ingredients.Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
Versatility and durability make this roasting genus Pan a lynchpin in the kitchen , consummate for roasting pith or organise one - goat god dishes like casseroles and lasagne . While it is n’t lightweight , it ’s built to last if care for decent .
Product detail : Dimensions:16 x 14 x 3 inches |Materials : untarnished steel |Rack Included : Yes |Lid Included : No |Care : Dishwasher safe , hand lavation recommend
Best Budget
Farberware Nonstick Steel Roaster
Even though it was one of the cheap roasting pans we tested , it equally cooked both chicken and potatoes .
It ’s a bit smaller than other roasting goat god on our lean .
For those looking for an affordable roasting pan , this is the good option for you . While this is one of the least expensive ridicule pans we tested , it was also one of the highest playing .
After cook a chicken and tater in this roasting pan , we found the chicken to be absolutely and equally roasted , and the Irish potato had a crispy exterior with a flossy , pillowy interior .
When it was time to pick the pan , we found it to be evenhandedly aboveboard to strip with a mild mantrap goop and water . While its flat shape made the rack easy to clean , washing each incision of the wire wrack sufficiently took a few extra minute . Despite this , the roasting pan earned a unadulterated grade for ease of cleaning since the pan itself did n’t require any difficult scrubbing .
Keep in mind that this genus Pan ca n’t withstand the direct heat or opened fire of a kitchen range top , and should only be used in the oven . Compared to our best overall plectron , this genus Pan is a second minor , so you may want to choose for a slightly larger goat god if you are cooking for a crowd or large family .
Because of its exceptional performance at an low-cost price point , this roasting genus Pan earned a score of 5 out of 5 star paygrade during our examination , stool it ideal for those see for a budget - well-disposed alternative .
Product Details : Dimensions:11.3 x 2.4 x 16 in |Materials : Stainless sword |Rack included : Yes |Lid included : No |Care : Hand dry wash only
Best Splurge
Hestan Provisions Classic Roaster with Rack
It make a thoroughly cooked doll in slightly less than an minute , and a tasty well - developed fond for the gravy to go with it .
The groove around the border beguile drippings , but also limits the amount you ’ll have for that tasty gravy .
If you do n’t mind spending a little extra on the right ridicule pan , this is the best one for you . We found it lend plenty of strike for the buck , and minus a couple of points for cleaning issue , we feel it outmatch other more expensive brands .
During our examination , we encounter that this pan roasted a bird thoroughly after about an hour . Although the color on theroasted chickenwasn’t as even as other roasting pans we tested , it still develop a mouth - tearing meal .
This roasting pan was also able-bodied to produce a nice fond formaking a volaille gravyon the bottom of the genus Pan . We also liked that the goat god has a groove around the bound for catch the drippings from the razz , which is handy , but also limits the amount of liquidness you ’ll be capable to use for gravy subsequently on .
This roasting pan does fall with a rack , but we found it did n’t quite have as much room underneath as other pans we quiz . We were able to accommodate Irish potato under the rack , but it was a squiffy convulsion . However , this roasting pan yielded delicious potatoes that were caramelized and larder .
After we cooked the chicken and potatoes , there was a little spot of bond - on food , but it came off after some scrub . Although we opted to cancel this pan during our examination , we do appreciate that the pan and stand are both dishwasher safe .
While it is true to its untarnished steel name and cleans easily for the most part , we did find that it tarnish slightly from the potato starch we cooked in it . Otherwise , the performance of the pan was exemplary and clear an overall rating of 4.3 out of 5 adept .
Product detail : Dimensions:12.5 x 3.5 x 18.5 column inch |Materials : Stainless steel |Rack include : Yes |Lid included : No |Care : dish washer secure
Best Stainless Steel
Cuisinart MultiClad Pro Roasting Pan
It develop a utterly prepare chicken , has supportive handle , and is dishwashing machine safe .
Because the potatoes were slenderly overcook , the cleanup process was a little tiresome .
If you ’re looking for astainless steeloption , this is the best stainless steel roasting pan we essay . This pan roasted a perfect , equally embrown chicken . However , the potatoes were a little overdone and a petty too crispy , so we commend taking the murphy out of the oven while the bird finish cooking .
This roasting genus Pan is oven safe up to 500 ° F , and stovetop good up to around a medium high-pitched heat . Its outside is brushed stainless steel with an aluminium core , and it add up with a slightly U - shaped rack that is gently slosh on the sides and a two-dimensional bottom to hold your roast .
The stainless steel handles are focus in place for a safe and safe grip , and they stay nerveless for comfortable gripping while cooking . We also like that it has a commodious pouring rim that prevents drop , too .
Because the potato got overcooked during testing , we find thatcleaning the stainless steel panrequired some endeavor and scrubbing . However , we do appreciate that this option is dishwasher good , unlike some other roasting pans on our list .
Although you may have to make some readjustment withroasting vegetableswith this pick , it earned one of our top daub because of its power to jest at a flawless volaille .
Product Details : Dimensions:12.1 x 5.2 x 19.3 inches |Materials : untarnished blade , aluminum |Rack included : Yes |Lid included : No |Care : Dishwasher good
Best Ceramic
GreenPan Reserve Nonstick Roasting Pan
It ’s various , has a great nonstick capability , and is excellent for cooking proteins and one - stool initiation .
The volaille slid around slimly on the rack .
Thisceramic panis nonpareil for the habitation James Cook who is take care for an effective roasting pan to handle their protein and occasional one pot meal . It ’s also a great choice for those who care about kitchen aesthetics , as this is a silklike , forward-looking - looking genus Pan .
Regarding the goat god ’s performance , it was mention that while the roast was perfectly golden chocolate-brown after cooking for about an hour , the skin was crispy in some places but not others . After about 15 hour , the white potato looked brown and start to caramelise .
However , after misrepresent with the wimp for an hour , the potatoes end up overdone , dark , and crunchy . If you use this rib pan to make side , you may want to remove them before the chicken is polish off cooking . The godsend was placid and well - incorporated .
It was also incredibly easy to clean , and stuck - on solid food came off effortlessly with just a few swipe of the rough side of a scrub brush sponge . Because of this , we gave it a 5 out of 5 wiz valuation for comfort of cleaning . It ’s also technically safe for the dishwasher — but the manufacturer does recommend paw washing in quick soapy water system for good results .
While the handles made the pan simple to maneuver with just the potatoes in it , the fin - shaped wheel leaves a piddling too much way between its side of meat and the pan . This meant that once the knock was added , we noticed that it did slew around a bit .
Unlike a few other options on our list , it ’s safe to use metal utensil with this roasting pan because of its shekels - resistant surface . It can also be used on gas and galvanic stovetops . Overall , this ceramic laugh at pan gain a score of 4.1 out of 5 , making it one of the best product we tested .
mathematical product Details : Dimensions:13.25 x 2.5 x 16.25 inch |Materials : Ceramic , PFAS - Free nonstick surface , aluminum , stainless steel |Rack include : Yes |Lid included : No |Care : Dishwasher safe , paw wash drawing recommended
Best Nonstick
All-Clad Stainless Steel Nonstick Roasting Pan
This genus Pan can roast turkeys up to 25 pound and has a removable rack that doubles as a baking dishful .
It was a little unmanageable to get the drippings out to make gravy .
This versatile roaster can function as a baking stunner when the wrack is removed , and it conveniently works on gas , ceramic , and galvanizing cooktops , as well as in the oven . Both the rack and the roasting pan are nonstick , and it ’s safe for temperature of up to 500 ° F in the oven .
After fix the chicken for an hour and one instant , it had a light , crispy experience to its skin . The volaille was a petty bit light on the bottom , but that may be due to the close propinquity of the rack to the tater we put in with it . When we checked the potatoes after the same amount of time , they were unevenly brown with a few on the crispy side , and some still a little blonde on the bottom . All of the potatoes were perfectly creamy on the inside , however .
The gravy had a well - blend consistency , although it did require a bit of operate to get enough of the dripping out of the grooved sharpness of the pan to make it .
Because of the nonstick purpose of this cooking pan , cleanup spot was swift and soft , which earned this laugh at pan a score of 5 out of 5 for simplicity of cleanup . We recommend hop-skip any harsh detergents , blade woollen , bleach cleansers , nonstick spray , or alloy utensils on this pan as they might damage the nonstick surface . However , nylon scrubbing pads are okay to use .
Credit: Amazon
Product particular : Dimensions:13 x 5 x 16 inches |Materials : unstained steel |Rack let in : Yes |Lid included : No |Care : Dishwasher dependable
Best with Lid
GraniteWare Large Oval Roasting Pan
It can accommodate up to 20 Cypriot pound of meat , pee-pee it a groovy choice for holiday preparation .
It go far in somewhat challenging packaging , with a toughie that ’s difficult to transfer .
This enameled roasting goat god from Granite Ware develop excellent cooking results , and its versatility and economic value for the terms make it our favorite choice with a chapeau .
Our chicken was evenly roasted in the Farberware Nonstick Steel Roaster.Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
During examination , we were impressed with the pan ’s results across the circuit card . With a durable yet lightweight pattern , this roaster hold out mellow temperature – up to 932 ° F – so you may roast and broil a variety of item .
We found this ridicule pan effective at evenly cooking chicken without overcook the Irish potato , mushrooms , and onions with it . Its large size can accommodate large cuts of meat up to 20 pounds , establish it a great option for roasting turkeys and holiday meal .
The pan ’s nonstick surface makes it suitable for cookery soups and stovetop sauces as well , but keep in mind it should not be used on induction or glass cooktops . We like that the goat god is made with materials that are free from toxins like PFOA and PTFE for a safer cookery experience . It can also be washed in the dishwashing machine , get to cleanup easy and commodious .
The only disappointment with this roaster was a sticker that was difficult to remove when we first unboxed it . A pocket-sized price to pay , however , given that we think the Granite Ware guy genus Pan is a great value that is well - designed for both everyday purpose and special occasions .
Product Details : Dimensions:19.3 x 13.8 x 8.3 inch |Materials : Enamel |Rack Included : No |Lid Included : Yes |Care : Dishwasher safe
Best Cast Iron
Le Creuset Enameled Cast Iron Signature Rectangular Roaster
This pan is eminent - quality and well designed , and the miscellany of colors available make it an attractive objet d’art to exhibit on the stovetop or table .
It is very heavy and can be a challenge to clean .
This beautiful and durable roasting pan by Le Creuset is a voguish choice for place chef looking for an investiture piece that ’s made to last . Enameled cast atomic number 26 assure even heat dispersion for first-class cooking resultant , and it is available in multiple colorways to ordinate with your kitchen aesthetic .
design to transition well from stove to oven to table , this pan is compatible with all cooktops and oven - safe up to 500 ° farad . It ’s various enough to poke fun heart and vegetables , broil casseroles and desserts , and make stovetop sauces . During testing , we found that it poke fun volaille and vegetables perfectly .
While the pan is made from the lightest weight cast iron on the market , we still detect it very toilsome , make it challenging to point and wash out by hand . We care that it is good to use with metallic element utensil , and while many cast iron pans postulate flavouring , this one comes quick to expend .
The size of the goat god is idealistic for everything from macaroni and tall mallow to cinnamon roll and your Thanksgiving turkey , although it does n’t get along with a rack or palpebra . Despite its weightiness , this roaster ’s eminent - quality construction and table - worthy appeal makes it an heirloom bit suitable of the monetary value .
merchandise Details : Dimensions:16 x 10.25 x 3 inches |Materials : Enameled throw iron |Rack include : No |Lid Included : No |Care : Dishwasher - safe , script washing recommend
The Bottom Line
Overall , the best roasting pan on our list is theWilliams Sonoma Stainless Steel Ultimate Roaster with Rack . We care that it ’s made of long-lived stainless blade and has a nice look to it , so it do for a decent presentation on the table .
Our Testing Process
We put 24 of the best roasting pans to the test by preparing roasted Gallus gallus and Irish potato , cautiously travel along the same recipe for each roasting pan . After ridicule the chicken and potatoes , we reserve the drippings to make gravy . While testing , we valuate each pan and considered its intent , performance , relaxation of cleansing , and value .
For pattern , we look intimately at each pan ’s shape , capacity , material , and characteristic like handles . When cooking the Gallus gallus and potatoes , we count the style the pan ’s heat was distribute , its aura stream , whether foods stuck to it , and how well it fake the foods . For some models , we also evaluate the in high spirits temperature the pan can withstand , and whether it can be used on the stovetop as well as in the oven .
Regarding ease of cleaning , we explored how easy the pan is to clean by manus , whether it ’s dish washer - good , and whether it had nonstick surfaces that made it gentle to clean house . When assess value , we determined whether the pan performed as advertised and if we considered it worth the price . After considering all of these factors , we rated each roasting pan and chose the best ones found on our examination operation .
What To Know About Roasting Pans Before Shopping
Dimensions
When it comes to roasting pans , size can vary so you ’ll want to consider both what you need to misrepresent and what your kitchen can manage .
“ Since oven size can vary , be sure your roasting pan will fit easily into your oven . There are even bantam - sized roasting pan for some countertop ovens , ” saysArt Jackson , atomic number 27 - founder of Pleasant House Pub .
You ’ll require to take into story the size of your oven ’s interior as well as any grip and lids that add extra meridian and width .
While it ’s best to get the proper size of it for your roast , if you do end up with a larger pan size of it than you need , test to fill the extra space up with chop vegetable and a piece of water , broth , or wine to keep the dripping from combust .
Materials
Roasting pans can be made of a variety of materials , include aluminium , untarnished steel , C blade , and ceramic . Jackson recommend hard , anodized atomic number 13 with a non - stick coating as it has great heat retention and is well-fixed to houseclean .
However , Gillett recommends stainless steel , such as theCuisinart Multiclad Pro Triple Ply Stainless Cookware 16 - Inch Roasting Pan Skillet , especially for those with less cookery experience . “ I ’m a stainless steel rooter . I think for the casual dwelling house cook , it is various and easy to conserve , ” he enjoin . “ It can take a whacking and be sword unexampled for the next function . ”
Features
When choosing a make fun pan for your kitchen , you ’ll also want to consider any extra characteristic that it comes with .
While a rack is n’t necessarily imperative , it does have its benefits in a roasting pan . Generally , racks are helpful for holding your knock up off the bottom of your roasting pan , keeping it above its own dripping so the skin can get crisp and taut . It also helps with airflow which promotes even roasting .
calculate upon the type of cooking you ’ll be doing , you may want to consider a chapeau with your roasting pan . Plenty of roasting pans do n’t make out with lids and they get the Book of Job done without them . However , lids also have advantage for your preparation , like keeping the moisture in when steaming , for juicier meats , or preventing messy heart from splattering inside your oven .
“ Using Al foil to substitute as a lid is an loose way to work around your genus Pan not coming with a palpebra . This could also be a distance saver in the theater deliberate the size of the genus Pan and lid , ” says Gillett .
Shape
In monastic order to cook your food optimally , you ’ll want to look for either a rectangular or oval - shaped cooking pan . orthogonal roast pans have more roasting versatility as they provide a greater cooking area , while ovals are great for snarf roasts up above their juice , ensuring crispy skin , wanton basting , and even browning .
Meanwhile , make fun pans with flat bottoms are ideal for stovetop cooking as you ’ll believably want less pooling of juice around the boundary . hold can add helpful lifting assistance and portability when needed .
Care
When take a roasting genus Pan for your kitchen , care is an of import point to conceive in more path than one . For instance , if you have an oversized option that ’s hand - wash only , you ’ll have to check you have a sink with child enough to strip it . If you entertain often , a dishwashing machine - safe pick is one less affair to interest about when you houseclean .
“ A roastingpan with non - stick coatingwill be easy to scavenge with a simple soak if necessary and a diffused scrubber , ” Jackson tell .
Other Roasting Pans We Tested
OXO Obsidian Pre-Seasoned Carbon Steel Roasting Pan
TheOXO Obsidian Roasting Panis made with carbon paper steel and oven - good up to 600 ° F , making it versatile and well - designed for even cooking . We found the nonstick surface to be specially effective .
The roaster includes a V - shaped stainless steel roasting rack which is a nice plus , however during examination we found a few expanse for melioration . While the pan is pre - veteran , we found that it requires re - seasoning , and was difficult to care for since it ’s not dishwasher safe .
The pan offers solid functioning for basic roasting and works well for smaller birds and cuts of marrow , however there are better options available at alike or low price pointedness .
Five Two Essential Roasting Pan and Rack
TheFive Two Essential Roasting Panand Rack is oven and broiler secure up to 600 ° F , and both its rack and roaster can be toss in the dishwasher for an casual post - meal cleanup , or mildly washed by hand with warm soapy water and a soft parazoan . It ’s also various with initiation compatibility , and amount fit out with a 360 - degree pouring brim that can tilt and pelt from any slant without disgorge .
However , the rack sit extremely low-down in the cooking pan , making it expectant for roasting protein but not much else . Anything smaller , like vegetables , pose too penny-pinching up under the roast , and cooked to crispness ( or even overcooked ) in reveal areas but scarcely at all in the covered surface area . Considering the steep toll tag , it underperformed and did not gain our recommendation .
All-Clad Stainless Steel Flared Roasting Pan
TheAll - Clad Stainless Steel Flared Roasting Panhas flame up , low English , a matt rack that also catch one’s breath quite low , and a outstandingly expectant surface orbit . It ’s ideal for gas and electric cooktops , and is oven and broiler dependable , resist up to 600 ° F .
There were a few drawbacks to this model , like its uneven heating plant statistical distribution ( some bits were burn on the bottom during testing , and the joint did n’t get browned equally on the exterior ) , and its Earth’s surface area requires a range of square size to gibe on the stovetop for manna from heaven making or other cooktop preparations .
We determined there are good choice usable for the price as well as the amount of quad it require up in the kitchen . We felt it would be best used for defecate sail pan dinner party or roast vegetables — but probably not meat roast .
Nordic Ware Copper Roaster XL Large
TheNordic Ware Copper Roaster XL Largeroasting genus Pan has a large U - shaped wrack large enough for a 25 - pound Meleagris gallopavo . It ’s oven - secure up to 450 ° fluorine and has a nonstick , wanton - to - clean surface . However , the chicken did n’t cook evenly and the tater ended up mostly overcooked . This make fun cooking pan also is n’t dishwashing machine safe . Because of its poor performance , it earned low score throughout our testing .
Your Questions, Answered
Is stainless steel or aluminum better for a roasting pan?
Aluminum is a great heat music director and is lightweight and relatively cheap . However , anodized aluminum has the potential to react with or percolate into foods , sometimes making it problematical when used with highly acid food or those that must remain heated over a extended period of meter .
Stainless sword is known for its durability and warmth retention , and tends to work well both in the oven and on the stovetop . It also circulate oestrus evenly and is well-heeled to cleanse when used decently .
Should roasting pans have deep or shallow sides?
This is mostly a matter of predilection and depends on what kind of food you ’ll be roast .
Roasting pans with higher , deeper sides are excellent for declamatory meatroasts like turkeys , especially when a lot of juices are expected to be drawn from them while cooking . Shallow sides are best for sunbaked vegetables , smaller cut of meat , and fish that you wo n’t require a lot of drip from .
“ Thickness and high side bring home the bacon heavy insulation and heat retention and way for thick lasagna , casseroles , and roasted marrow and vegetable dish with gravy , ” Jackson say .
Does a roasting pan need a rack?
Not every roast pan comes with a stand , though it ’s definitely a key detail to view . Most chefs do be given to favour one when available .
“ Roasting pans do n’t always need a wheel , but it ’s a good add-on to have if you ’re preparing meat or vegetable roasts that you would like to have roasting above pan drippings and gravy , ” Jackson says . “ The rack will leave the roast to be easily removed from the pan and the gravy to be finish in the same pan . ”
If your pan does n’t have a stand , however , Gillett recommends using veggie on the bottom of your pan as an alternative . This humbled layer will help keep whatever you ’re roasting off the bottom of the pan .
Who We Are
KJ Callihanis a writer for Better Homes & Gardens who has focused on rest home gear , health , pets , and sleep products . To make this tilt , she organize the results of our roasting pan testers , with an emphasis on dimensions , materials , and lineament include ( like racks or lids ) . She also try the expert direction ofArt Jackson , cobalt - laminitis of Pleasant House Pub , andMatt Gillett , co - owner of Saddleback Barbecue and The Slice , for additional insight .
BHG contributorJordan Liberty Phillipsalso updated this article . Her expertise include recipe and cooking , home decor , and shopping .
BHG Recommends
Next to all of the merchandise on this list , you may have noticed our BHG Recommends seal of approval . Products that reset the sealing wax have been put through rigorous testing to check that they ’re worth a blot in your home . We grease one’s palms most of the product we test ourselves , but occasionally we are provided samples by company if buying is n’t an option . In these typeface , we practice the same testing criteria we use to test the purchased products .
Credit: Amazon
This Hestan Provisions pick has a groove around the edge for catching the chicken’s drippings.Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
Credit: Target
The rim on this Cuisinart pick helps prevent drips, which is ideal while roasting.Credit:Better Homes & Gardens
Credit: Amazon
After about 15 minutes, the potatoes looked brown and started to caramelize in this GreenPan pick.Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
Credit: Amazon
After an hour of roasting in this All-Clad pick, the potatoes were perfectly creamy on the inside.Credit:Better Homes & Gardens
Credit: Amazon
We were able to evenly cook chicken without overcooking the other food in this GraniteWare pot.Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
Credit: Amazon
We used this Le Creuset model to cook chicken and vegetables during testing.Credit: Better Homes & Gardens
Credit:Better Homes & Gardens
Credit:Better Homes & Gardens
Credit:Better Homes & Gardens
